When you sit in one place and watch, inevitably you see. Wild things come to you, by sound and by sight. This afternoon, in the shirt-drenching heat of the Três Irmâos river, we sat and we waited, and we saw and we heard.
Always there were yellow-billed cardinals and lesser kiskadees along the bank of the river, among the twisted roots of the trees. Always there were ringed kingfishers, sometimes Amazon kingfishers too. Always a cocoi heron fished just upriver. There were many birds I was unable to point out to my group as we were sitting in silence, waiting, watching. Of the birds I saw and heard for my silent self, all were old friends. Rusty-backed spinetails stammered in the overhanging brush and pale-legged horneros shrieked in antiphony from the bank. Grey-headed tanagers bounced over the river calling, and in the trees’ canopy a hooded tanager fed.
I could not point them out because, in the blanket of humid heat, we were waiting for movement. On the opposite bank, flat-out and barely half seen, was a blotch-spattered form in the dust. This was Peter. Behind a tree, unseen by the whole group, except me, just occasionally a black ear with a white splotch would move, or the curve of a spotted neck. This was Bianca.
Jaguars. A courting pair, both well-known local cats. For all of my clients, their first. For a long hot time, nothing happened, though Peter occasionally lifted his heavy head and once he yawned. His face was battered and scarred and half of his left ear missing. He was, I guessed, and later Fiorella confirmed, some eight or nine years old. A male at the peak of his strength, with the wounds of battle all around his tired eyes.
Thanks to this strength, beside him lay Bianca, hidden from view by a tree. After two hours she stretched, she stood, she looked, and I could see from her face that she was much younger. I guessed four or five and Fiorella later agreed. She walked to Peter and slumped behind him. All eyes watched, thrilled, delighted, moved.
Sleep; again sleep. Heat. Then, of all the unpredicted turns, another jaguar, a bigger male, appeared by the river upstream, walking towards our pair. No identifying features could be seen on him - too far, too fast - but here, clearly, was an interloper, a young male drawn by the hold of Bianca's scent on his hormones. We heard his padded footfall on the forest’s dry leaves and, in an instant, Bianca stood, roared deeply and bolted downstream. Peter went with her, roaring too.
They turned to the unseen incomer and they stared. A checkered checkmate in the leaf-dappled light of the late afternoon. The suitor desisted, the cats relaxed, and so did we, as the lesser kiskadees looped over the water and the undulated tinamous sang their sad song to the lengthening shadows. As relaxed, that is, as my group of eleven naturalists could be having just seen their first three jaguars on the bank of a river in Brazil.
Cats seen in 2015
cheetah Acinonyx jubatus fearonii 3
serval Leptailurus serval serval 3
leopard Panthera pardus suahelicus 2
lion Panthera leo nubica 78
The Transpantaneira is as extraordinary a road as you will find in the world anywhere. Built to bring cattle off the Pantanal, it stripes south in a straight line from Cuiabá to Porto Jofre, crossing on its way the many habitats of the world’s greatest freshwater wetland.
Black howler monkeys and their pale gold females weave through the trees by the road in the cool of morning. Beyond them silvery marmosets skip mercurial along the finest fronds, fizzing loudly as they go. A toco toucan swoops across the road, its bill in the early light the orange of a too-boiled carrot.
In the dying drying marshes egrets crowd and storks, feasting on the corralled fish and crabs. Coatis wave their banded tails in the shade of a palm and laughing falcons scowl – unamused – from the tops of stranded marsh trees.
A pygmy kingfisher – habitually a skulker in the shade – blazes bright on a perch over a small pool and nearby, in the Cyperus stands, scarlet-headed blackbirds blaze yet brighter still; the colour of their heads too saturated to be believed. A marsh deer grazes, leggy and black-nosed, and all the while vultures - black, turkey, lesser yellow-headed – cross the marsh, the forest and the road, hungering for life and death and a meal.
We reach Porto Jofre in fine time, the dirt road having just been graded. Then, from the boat which takes us to our floating hotel in the heart of the jaguar’s crisscross of rivers and creeks, there are black skimmers, pied lapwings, yellow-billed and large-billed terns.
At the hotel there is news of jaguars; a pair which for two days has been courting, resting, mating even, in the forest edge upriver. Whether they will be there this afternoon we cannot know. But we shall be there.
In Gujarat, in March, in what seems another life, I wrote a post about animals with big ears: striped hyenas and wolves in Velavadar. All the better for losing heat with. Last night it was the turn of the big noses.
It is bruisingly hot at Pouso Alegre, far hotter than is typical in late September. Thus it is dry; and the animals of the gallery forest are concentrated around the few remaining water holes. Yesterday evening we went to a water hole in the edge of the forest where Brazilian tapirs regularly come to drink in the last of the light.
Tapirs, as is well known, have big noses. All the better for sniffing with, and snorkelling while swimming in the murky waters of South America's lowland rivers. What comes first to drink, however, out-noses a tapir by far. It out-tails it too. It more or less out-everythings a tapir.
Over the dam of this last water hole trundles a giant anteater and my group is at once electrified. This weirdest of animals pokes its nose through the mat of water hyacinths and drinks, long and deep, then sways off into the scrubby vegetation.
I wish I could wax lyrical, about the anteater, about the young male tapir which followed as the light began to fade, about the three further tapirs we saw by the road after dark, but last night wifi went down (we are, after all, in the far end of dusty nowhere) and I could not post. Right now we leave for Porto Jofre, the river and its jaguars. About silvery marmosets, great rufous woodcreepers and countless capybaras I cannot write more for now.
Last night was about noses. One absurdly long and inflexible, four rubbery and wildly mobile. All the better for sniffing with.
Picture the scene. 40 degrees in the shade (that's Celsius for my transatlantic readers). A campo flicker giggles in the heat and greater rheas pick through the fallen fronds of Attalea phalerata palms (the Bolivian in me wants to call these motacú, but here that would be quite wrong). Here, then, is Brazil, the Pantanal, and outside, despite the heat, despite their having started at four this morning, the Chaco chachalacas chunter demonically.
Brazil. Yes. And your correspondent is perched, barely clothed, in the doorway of his tiny bathroom. Barely clothed because the heat in the middle of the day is unrelenting. In the bathroom because here is my only plug. There is wifi though. Wifi in a place where, when I left South America eight years ago, it would have been unimaginable. And my clients, with better access to plugs, are happy. Happy, to use the vernacular, as peccaries in shit.
I too am happy. In a way beyond words. Because here in central South America I'm home. I lived the other side of the border in Bolivia, yes, but these birds, these mammals, trees, pampas and forest islands are a home I made for myself during ten years here. Yesterday, having flown all night, as we drove from Cuiabá, past Poconé, to the beautiful ranch called Pouso Alegre, the birds, the mammals and the flowers came to me as from my heart. My home.
I have come to Brazil, of course, to look for jaguars. I would understand, though, if you thought I had desisted from my quest. If you thought that cats had dropped from my horizon. I have not written here in so very long.
And for this a few words of apology. I meant to. I had a list of the topics I would cover. Of the cat species I would discuss. Of the conservationists I would contact. Of the breeding programmes I would visit. I had a plan. But when I got home from Asia in May I was contacted by Norfolk Wildlife Trust with requests to lead on two exciting projects - a book and a local TV series - and somehow my summer was consumed by them.
I put down my pen (or, rather, sent my last Word file) on my contribution to the book on Thursday. On Friday I boarded a plane to Brazil, having not picked up a single book on the subject. And on Saturday I was driven, with my group and my superbly talented colleague Fiorella, down the Transpantaneira, yelping with delight as each old friend trotted by the track, swooped through the trees or belched in the water hyacinth wallows by the roadside. Red-legged seriema (the socori of my Bolivian days), toco toucan, yacaré caimans (in their thousands), crab-eating foxes and equally crab-eating racoons, orange-backed troupials (for you Tim: a glorious eye-thump) and - as I type these words their calls blare across the ranch - hyacinth macaws, greatest of all the world's parrots.
I am home. I am happy. I am hot. I will be looking for jaguars and writing here. I gave my word that I would. I would be honoured, on this South American leg of my adventures, if you would follow me as I do.
It seems an age since I returned to the UK from Asia. It seems a different marsh tit who was there. But there are photographs to show that I was there and from time to time my lovely clients send them to me. The first, of snow ninjas in the Rumbak Valley (the things you do to stay warm while looking for snow leopards), is by Richard Hurrell. The rest, from Tadoba and Kanha in Central India, are by Graham and Tina Nuthall. As always I'm in shorts in Central India and quite often I'm barefoot, my spindly legs waving from the side of the gypsy. When wearing sandals they are dangling, barely strapped from my feet. Some things never change.
Thanks to Richard, Tina, Graham and all my Asia clients in 2015, for their photos and for their humorous good company watching big cats in India.
Written on 31st May, published with the agreement of the press team at RZSS and other interested parties
My conversation with Doug Richardson of RZSS Highland Wildlife Park did not restrict itself to the plight of the Scottish wildcat. Far from it. The park is home to four further species of wild cat, with a fifth to arrive in the near future. Here therefore are more thoughts which Doug and I ping-ponged between ourselves on Sunday morning.
Amur tiger Panthera tigris altaica
The Amur tiger is the largest subspecies of the world's largest cat and is restricted to the southern far east of Russia and, historically, bordering areas of China. It is characterised by its light orange coat, dense fur, rather weak black stripes and extensive areas of white in its cheeks and throat. It is magnificent and on Sunday I spent far too long cooing over Highland Wildlife Park's three cats.
As magnificent as it is, the Amur tiger is also desperately threatened. Until very recently it was essentially extinct in China and well on its way to extinction in Russia. Still today, though WWF claims this week that there are now 540 wild Amur tigers, this subspecies is critically endangered. Some believe this figure to be inflated and one source reports that there may be only 40 reproductive individuals in the wild population. And every single individual that has ever been radio-collared, Doug says, has been poached in the end. Every one.
Happily, if there is any happiness in this situation, the captive population is known to be genetically pure, a far better situation than pertains with the Scottish wildcat. At Highland Wildlife Park there are currently three Amur tigers, an adult pair and their male youngster born in 2013. He will soon move to form half of a new breeding pair at a zoo in Germany, just as a sibling from the same litter recently went to Switzerland. The adults live in a large birch-scrub enclosure which hints at the taiga home of the species in Amur.
Doug has such experience with cats in captivity that he is husbandry advisor on the Europe-wide breeding programmes for both Amur and Sumatran tigers. It is with his eyes on Amur that he passionately argues for the need to keep this subspecies in captivity in the Scottish Highlands. He feels, and his argument is borne out by reintroductions across the world, that without the husbandry skills gained through breeding an animal in captivity we cannot hope to return it to its natural environment. Critically, also, in the case of large, severely threatened carnivores, without captive populations there can quite simply not be enough individuals, or enough genetic diversity, to restitute a healthy wild population in the future. Already, Doug says, there are genetic dynasties of the Amur tiger in captivity, which are known to have disappeared in the wild.
It is a sad world indeed in which we talk in these terms. But it is the world we inhabit.
Vying with the Ngorongoro lion for the position of
coolest selfie to date
Pallas's cat Otocolobus manul
I've always thought it rather unfair that Pallas has so many marvellous animals named after him: a powerful eagle, the most dramatic gull, the most delicate and enchanting leaf-warbler, the snazziest grasshopper warbler, the most evocative sandgrouse. However, where cats are concerned Pallas drew, if not the short straw, the strangest of straws. Pallas's cat is weird.
Highland Wildlife Park has an excellent record of breeding and raising Pallas's cats, a species which, Doug tells me, can be difficult to rear to adulthood on account of its susceptibility to toxoplasmosis. Last year, thanks to veterinary advances, Highland Wildlife Park raised an exceptional six Pallas's kittens.
The Royal Zoological Society of Scotland coordinates the European breeding programme and international studbook for Pallas's cat. It also supports research into Pallas's cats in their wild range, funding camera-trapping campaigns in Mongolia, Iran, Nepal and Kazakhstan. The intention is to map the species' distribution with greater accuracy and to explore the veracity of the cat's supposed subspecies. More information on RZSS's work with Pallas's cats may be found here.
The Pallas's cats are currently off exhibit,
so I took this as a surrogate.
Northern lynx Lynx lynx lynx
The park has recently, quite strategically, changed from keeping Carpathian lynxes to keeping northern lynxes, aquiring one adult of Swedish origin and another of Latvian. Doug is quite clear on the rationale behind this. Until a few hundred years ago when we extinguished the lynx in the UK, it would have been northern lynx which inhabited our island. It is therefore, Doug argues, important for a facility within a region in which lynx might one day be reintroduced to maintain the correct subspecies, principally for local stakeholders to be able to see the living animal in the flesh.
It is also crucially important for animals which might one day be released to have been raised in a way which minimises their likelihood of coming into conflict with humans and their livestock; and for the local institutions involved to build good relationships over time with those whose livelihoods could in theory be affected. The reintroduction of a large carnivore is not a question of opening cage doors. It is a question of people, institutions, stakeholders in a landscape working together over decades for the good of wild species and their wildnerness.
Doug is not a man to shy from such challenges. As he talks, from his position of immense knowledge and experience, you can feel him mentally rolling up his sleeves to take on a tough gig. For now his lynxes are breeding successfully at the park, with two new kittens born last week, and they are proving very popular with visitors.
How my northern lynx selfie worked out
How I'd hoped it would work out
Amur leopard Panthera pardus orientalis
It might seem obvious that a zoo should prominently display charismatic animals in its collection in order to draw in the crowds. Think pandas at Edinburgh Zoo. It might seem obvious, yes, but that's not what RZSS and Doug have in mind for Amur leopards.
In July this year Highland Wildlife Park begins construction of a large enclosure for Amur leopards in an area of birch and juniper scrub at the top of the park. It will never be seen by visitors. Its aim, Doug explains, is not to display a breeding pair of Amur leopards to the public, but to welcome established breeding pairs from other instituions (obviating the need for the complex and potentially dangerous process of introducing a new pair to one another) and, in a very naturalistic enclosure, encourage them to raise young which are wild enough to go back to the wild.
The wild population of Amur leopards has reached critical levels, with some experts suggesting that fewer than twenty individuals remain, and no-one believing there are more than fifty. Russian authorities plan to create a second, reintroduced population, within the historic range of the cat but outside its current wild range. Doug and his remarkable facility in the birchwoods would provide cubs for this project, to order, according to the new population's genetic needs. Established pairs from the captive breeding programme would visit RZSS's visionary Amur leopardarium in turn and their cubs would go straight back to the Russian far east, without losing their innate fear of humans. Via a huge soft-release enclosure in the taiga they would then join this new population of the subspecies in the wild.
Or almost of the subspecies. The trouble with Amur leopards in captivity is that one of the founders of the captive population, a female known as Founder 2, is now known not to have been an Amur leopard at all. As a result the captive population is around 12% impure. So the Amur leopard in captivity (and therefore the founder stock of Russia's proposed new wild population) is faced by the same problem as the Scottish wildcat. It is not exactly what it says on the tin. The romantic end of the conservation community may well decry the Russian government's iniative, believing it better to lose the Amur leopard altogether than to dilute it with non-local genes.
Certainly if nothing is done we shall soon lose the wild Amur leopard altogether. So, at the pragmatic end of the community, Doug would say that it is better to have an animal which is genetically closely similar to the Amur leopard than no animal at all. A hardline ecologist would no doubt say the same, as an ecosystem with a top predator, whether it be the pure original genetic form of the top predator or not, is a healthier ecosystem than one without.
Philosophy aside, Doug and his team will soon commence construction of a superb new enclosure for Amur leopards at Highland Wildlife Park. Uniquely it will be for leopards and not for humans; visitors will observe its inhabitants only via remote cameras. What happens to the leopard kits born in this enclosure may revolutionise our understanding of big cats in zoos.
Snow leopard Panthera uncia
Construction is also underway of a snow leopard enclosure in the heart of the Highland Wildlife Park. This large, open-topped enclosure includes a small rock face and a patch of light birch scrub. It abuts a paddock housing Turkmenian markhor and on occasion, while the snow leopards are inside holding pens, the markhor will graze the snow leopards' outdoor area, enriching the scent and sense experience of the landscape for both species.
In collaboration with Norden's Ark in Sweden, the snow leopard project at Highland Wildlife Park will support conservation of wild snow leopards led by the Snow Leopard Trust.
Snow leopard enclosure under construction
at the Highland Wildlife Park
Written on 31st May, published with the agreement of the press team at RZSS and other interested parties
I have been stagnant these past two weeks, my mind and body rebelling against the great pile of jobs which has built up during almost four months of travel. Over these two weeks I could-have-should-have-would-have prepared better for this trip to Scotland, read more, written more here (I still have a mountain of ideas from Asia), and generally been a more assiduous marsh tit. Instead my body and mind have been in rebellion.
Today, like a proverbial new broom, Doug Richardson swept into my life and filled my mind with ideas, with questions, and with excitement for this second, British stage of my Big Cat Quest. Doug is Head of Living Collections at the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland's Highland Wildlife Park. And well he should be. He has spent his working life in many of the world's finest zoos and is full of zeal for the role that responsible zoos can play in wildlife conservation on our pained and compromised planet.
Doug had kindly agreed to meet me today to talk about cats at the Highland Wildlife Park and for two hours this morning that's just what we did.
Our conversation was wide-ranging (geographically and intellectually), tangential (at times almost fractal), impassioned, and frequently expletive. Often when listening to zoo folk in the past I've been disappointed by their apparent lack of knowledge of wildlife where it belongs: in the wild. Not so with Doug. His range of experience and reference is enormous, embracing distant continents and diverse animal groups with ease. He cites obscure subspecies of cat and best practice for raising arctic ducks in captivity without pausing for breath, and has always a dark spark of humour in his eye. Here is a man who is passionate about wildlife and its conservation.
It so happens that his contribution to its conservation is in captivity.
We spoke of so many things that it would be impossible to list them all here. I shall summarise some of what we said of cats, species by species, mog by mottled mog, beginning (in this post) with our native wildcat.
Wildcat Felis silvestris grampia
Among the most threatened vertebrates in the UK is the wildcat. It is known as the Scottish wildcat by historic accident, for everywhere else in the UK we killed it off. It survived, by accident, only in the remotest and least tamed reaches of Scotland.
A second peril compounds this range restriction today: hybridisation with domestic cats. This has been recognised as a problem for some decades and as an acute problem for several years but in Doug's no-nonsense words, 'We kinda faffed about.'
Today no-one knows whether any pure wildcats remain in the UK for none has yet been found. I learn from Doug that this includes the captive population: of some 35 wildcats of Scottish origin in captivity he estimates that 20% are 'worth breeding from.' Genetic tests to identify these animals are ongoing.
Genetic tests are also applied, where they can be found and caught, to cats in the wild. As part of the recovery programme coordinated by Scottish Natural Heritage there will be a widespread campaign of trapping, led by RZSS, to establish where there are cats, how pure they are and (this is where controversy enters the equation) which few should be brought into captivity as the founders of a new, representative breeding population.
Hackles will doubtless have risen at that last statement. Bring them into captivity? It shouldn't be allowed! Why would SNH take away our wildest animal's wildness? The why of it is tragically easy to understand. For a very long time there have been domestic cats in the range of the wildcat. All domestic cats, Doug says, are descended from just six founder females of Middle Eastern origin. Middle Eastern wildcats, and their domestic inheritors, are genetically very distinct from European ones but interbreed freely with them and produce fertile offspring. This is precisely what they have been doing for generations, with the result that there are possibly no pure wildcats left in Scotland at all, not to mention the rest of Europe.
Two measures of purity are used to assess wildcats which are caught. The first is phenotypic, based on characteristics of pelage which are known markers of Scottish wildcats, and is carried out by Andrew Kitchener of the National Museums of Scotland. The second is genetic and is carried out by RZSS. The benchmark for what a pure Scottish wildcat ought to look like, and what it should be genetically, has been taken from museum skins and mounted specimens of the nineteenth century. On account of the lack of 100% pure animals identified thus far in the captive and wild populations, a lower genetic threshold must be applied regarding what is functionally a wildcat.
The fundamental problem is that even those wild animals deemed functional wildcats are still surrounded by feral cats and less pure hybrids. It is for this reason that Scottish Natural Heritage, the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland, Doug and many colleagues have accepted that in the short term the only solution for the wildcat is to take more animals into captivity, and there maintain and build a population of animals which genetically and phenotypically best represent the Scottish wildcat. Cats left to their own devices in the wild, through most of Scotland, will soon be wholly swamped by the genes of feral cats and an irreplaceable part of our island's biodiversity will be lost, through genetic attrition, forever.
RZSS and Highland Wildlife Park's role in this has several elements. The simplest (though by no means logistically simple) is that half-a-dozen relatively pure Scottish wilcats are kept at the park and are bred (I saw some adorable kittens today) under the studbook kept by the Aspinall Foundation at Port Lympne in Kent. Secondly through this same work Doug's team contributes to understanding of wildcat husbandry, and this will be critical as the species' conservation becomes, in the short term, more dependent on captive management. Such management of wildcats at the Highland Wildlife Park forms part of Scottish Wildcat Action (new website to be launched soon), a multidisciplinary approach to the conservation of the cat involving captive breeding, threat reduction in the wild in six priority areas of Scotland and extensive monitoring to assess the effectiveness of measures being taken.
In addition, the Highland Wildlife Park can act as a quarantine facility for animals which come into captivity, either through chance (such as orphan kittens) or as a result of deliberate trapping, and can facilitate the incorporation of animals of wild origin into the captive population. Critically the park has large areas which are off exhibit and in which genuinely wild animals can be kept away from the gaze of the public, safe from habituation to humans. It is very clear in the minds of all involved that wildcats, however much intervention is needed, must be kept wild.
It is the word wild and our romantic understanding of it that cause most controversy. Those of us who believe in the conservation of wildlife still hanker after a wilderness in which wildlife looks after itself. It offends us to think that wildlife should be brought into captivity in order to preserve it. The wild should be wild! When recently Craig Packer, director of the Serengeti Lion Project, and arguably the world's greatest authority on lions in Africa, declared on the basis of decades of research that the only way to save lions in the Serengeti was to fence this massive park he was vilified. Despite clear evidence that the lion is declining catastophically across Africa and that conflict with humans in the Serengeti is reaching a critical level, he was shouted down. There were even voices from the conservation community which argued that it would be better to have no Serengeti than a fenced Serengeti.
Doug has no time for such sentimentality (and nor in fact do I). My own response is to ask whether those who would rather have no Serengeti have been there, whether they have seen the phenomenal spectacle of its migrating herds and their attendant predators. To lose such a treasure by taking a holier-than-thou attitude towards conservation would be unforgivable.
Doug believes that the same applies to the wildcat in Scotland. The evidence that hybridisation is destroying the species apace is unassailable. Better therefore to be the custodians of some of the purest cats in captivity for a generation or two, until a solution to hybridisation can be found across wild landscapes, than to preside inactive over the extinction of this remnant of our primeval wildness.
If it were only that easy
My customary selfie,
this time with a Scottish wildcat
In the end, after a week of searching, I did manage to see a largely pure wildcat in the wild. The story of the encounter may be found here.